A restaurant manager interviews a job candidate at a quiet table.

Hiring hospitality staff: interviews, skills checks and paid trial shifts

A useful hospitality hiring process starts with a real vacancy, assesses the skills that matter and makes payment arrangements clear before anyone works. Use consistent questions and observed evidence. If you need someone to perform productive work while you assess them, arrange lawful paid employment rather than calling the work an unpaid trial.

This guide is for café, restaurant and bar managers choosing staff. It ends at the selection decision and handoff to induction. It is general operational information; confirm employment-system coverage, awards, minimum engagements, pay, discrimination and privacy requirements with the relevant authority or qualified adviser.

Define the vacancy before inviting candidates

Write down why the role is needed, the duties, the likely roster and the skills required at entry. Distinguish skills you need immediately from tasks you can teach. An experienced barista vacancy and a trainee café all-rounder vacancy should not use the same assessment standard.

Describe actual work rather than personality labels. “Can clarify an order and pass accurate information to the kitchen” is assessable. “Must have the right vibe” invites inconsistent decisions. If the position includes alcohol service or other regulated duties, identify the relevant credentials and verify them appropriately.

Confirm the employment framework before advertising. The applicable system can depend on the employer's structure. In Western Australia, both state and national systems operate; use Wageline's system guidance to establish the correct starting point.

Have the person responsible for payroll check classification and conditions against the actual duties. Do not choose an award merely because a neighbouring café uses it or assume a job title determines the answer.

For a café all-rounder, the assessment might cover order accuracy, communication, safe work habits, response to instructions and the skills needed for the advertised station. Decide what evidence would satisfy each criterion before meeting candidates.

Separate an essential requirement from a preference. Familiarity with your particular POS may be convenient without being essential. A candidate who asks a clear question and learns the process may be more suitable than someone who works quickly but guesses.

Use a short rating scale with written anchors. For example: “demonstrated independently”, “demonstrated with the stated support”, “not yet demonstrated” and “not assessed”. The last category matters: a task that was never offered should not become a negative score.

Keep the criteria proportionate to the vacancy. Do not build an elaborate assessment process for a small role simply because a template has space for more rows.

Make the invitation clear

Tell candidates where to attend, who they will meet, the expected length and what the assessment involves. Explain clothing or footwear requirements relevant to safe participation. Give a contact point for access needs or reasonable adjustments.

If paid work is planned, confirm the arrangements in advance through your employment and payroll process. Identify the rate and applicable conditions, how time will be recorded and when payment will occur. Check minimum engagement provisions rather than assuming the planned task duration is the payable duration.

Avoid asking candidates to attend an open-ended “quick trial” that becomes the entire lunch rush. A clear plan protects service as well as the candidate: the supervisor can prepare the station, maintain coverage and give the assessment proper attention.

Ask consistent interview questions

Use the same core questions for people applying for the same role, with follow-up questions to clarify their answers. Ask for relevant examples and explain that examples can come from other work or training where appropriate.

Useful prompts include: “What would you do if you could not confirm an ingredient for a customer?” and “Tell me how you would check an order when two similar drinks are waiting.” The answer should reveal a safe process, not familiarity with your preferred wording.

For availability, state the actual roster requirement and ask whether the person can meet it. Avoid questions about family plans, health diagnoses or other personal matters unrelated to the lawful requirements of the role. Discuss adjustments through an appropriate, respectful process.

Leave time for the candidate's questions. Unclear hours, supervision or duties may reflect an incomplete vacancy brief. Resolve those gaps instead of treating the candidate's request for clarity as a lack of enthusiasm.

Understand the narrow unpaid-demonstration distinction

The Fair Work hospitality fact sheet explains that a brief unpaid skills demonstration may be lawful when genuinely necessary to assess suitability for a vacancy, limited to demonstrating relevant skills and directly supervised throughout. It must not extend beyond what is reasonably needed. There is no universally safe unpaid duration for every role.

Fair Work also makes clear that productive work and extended assessment can create payment obligations. Agreement to work without pay does not by itself make an arrangement lawful. For managers who need to observe normal service work, planning a properly paid assessment avoids relying on an uncertain unpaid exception. Confirm the rules under the employment system that covers your business.

Do not use successive candidates to cover roster gaps. Do not replace payment with a meal, a promise of future shifts or the possibility of getting the job. Keep recruitment assessment separate from staffing the venue.

Plan a safe, supervised assessment

Choose tasks that genuinely test the criteria and can be observed safely. Name a supervisor who has enough time to explain the task, watch it and intervene. Do not allocate that person an unmanageable service workload at the same time.

Before work begins, cover the immediate safety information needed for the tasks: where to work, what equipment may be used, relevant hygiene controls, who can assist and how to stop or report a problem. A candidate should not be left alone with unfamiliar equipment because they described themselves as experienced.

Use a simulated order where it tests the skill adequately. If a task affects real customers, apply the venue's normal controls and lawful paid-work arrangements. Do not test allergen knowledge by allowing an unverified answer to reach a customer.

Stop the assessment if safe supervision cannot continue. A disrupted assessment is a planning issue to resolve, not a reason to mark a candidate down for work they could not fairly demonstrate.

Record observations rather than impressions

Use concise notes tied to the criteria. “Repeated the order, checked the modifier and asked the supervisor about the unclear item” is useful evidence. “Seems switched on” is not enough to support a comparison.

Record the instructions and support provided. If one candidate received a demonstration and another did not, their speed alone is not a fair comparison. Note interruptions, equipment faults and any changes to the planned task.

Avoid unnecessary personal information. Assessment notes should support a hiring decision, not become a collection of informal opinions about appearance, accent or private circumstances. Restrict access to the people involved in recruitment and set retention and deletion arrangements with appropriate advice.

A café all-rounder example

In this hypothetical example, a café needs an employee who can take accurate orders and support the floor. The manager plans a paid assessment under checked employment conditions, with a supervisor and three defined tasks.

First, the candidate enters a sample order after a POS demonstration. They correctly record two drinks but miss a modifier. They notice the mismatch during readback and correct it before confirming the order. The note records both the initial error and the successful check.

Second, the candidate responds to a simulated ingredient question. They do not guess. They explain that they would confirm the current information with the responsible person. The assessment records the escalation behaviour rather than expecting memorisation of an unseen menu.

Third, the candidate clears and resets a table using the demonstrated venue process. The supervisor observes the work and asks the candidate to explain what they would do if the cleaning supplies were missing. The answer identifies the supervisor and avoids improvising with an unknown chemical.

The manager now has evidence against three criteria. None of it proves the person will perform every task independently. The decision can identify training needs and feed them into induction if an offer is made.

Compare candidates fairly

Review the criteria before discussing overall impressions. Identify essential gaps, evidence of learning and the support the venue can realistically provide. Keep a distinction between “not suitable for this vacancy” and “could be suitable for a different role”.

If evidence is incomplete, decide whether another properly arranged assessment is justified. Do not quietly convert uncertainty into a string of unpaid shifts. Ask the employment adviser how further work should be structured and paid.

Reference checks should be relevant, consented to as appropriate and consistent with your process. Verify important credentials through appropriate channels. Do not contact a current employer unexpectedly or treat unverified social-media material as a reliable assessment record.

Record the decision and the reasons in plain language. The record should be understandable to another authorised manager without relying on the interviewer's memory.

Close the process and hand over to induction

Tell candidates when they can expect a decision and follow through. Where the timeline changes, give a brief update. Confirm that payment for work performed is processed regardless of whether the candidate receives an offer.

For the successful candidate, provide the required employment information and settle the role, conditions and start arrangements through your normal process. Then transfer relevant training needs to the hospitality staff induction checklist.

Give the induction supervisor specific information: “Needs practice with modifiers and end-of-order readback” is actionable. Avoid circulating recruitment notes that the supervisor does not need. Use the venue-data guide for general access and record-handling principles, alongside employment and privacy advice.

Your next action

Before the next candidate attends, complete one assessment plan: genuine vacancy, relevant criteria, questions, tasks, supervisor, safe-work preparation, payment arrangements and decision date. Ask payroll to check the work arrangements before the invitation goes out.

The Café Operations Pack includes induction support for the next stage. It is not a recruitment kit or employment-law assessment. The free Venue Opening Checklist can support later shift preparation, after recruitment and induction responsibilities are settled.

References

Source review date: 5 September 2026. Confirm current workplace, discrimination and privacy requirements for the employer and role.

Back to the Learning Centre